2019

Luke Gibbons – John Carroll University

2018

Henry Carroll – Wheeling Jesuit University

2017

Cole Costanzo – Walsh University

Jack O’Donnell – Ohio Northern University

Mike Rose – Iowa State University

Sam Wiglusz – The Ohio State University (Preferred Walk-On)

2016

Eric Sonntag – Malone University

Luke Strnad – Marist University

Nick Zakelj – Fordham University

2015

Andrew Siegman – Akron University

Tyler Tupa – Ohio University

2014

Evan Baschko – John Carroll University

Joe Mandato – Baldwin Wallace College

2013

Colton Czack – Duquense University

Jay Rose – Hillsdale College

Tim Tupa – Bowling Green State University

2012

Grant Cunningham – Ohio University

Tyler Tarnowski – Wilmington University

Tom Tupa – Miami University

Mike Tyler – Stanford University

2011

Will Hubert – Mount Union University

Ryan Kelly – Ohio Dominican University

Rody Seballos – Ohio Northern University

2010

Adam Best – Ohio Northern University

Matt Galland – Air Force University

Danny Seafler – Akron University

2008

Mike Lannigan – Notre Dame College – MVP of East/West All Star Game in 2009